High employee turnover is a persistent and expensive problem for businesses, particularly within the sales sector. Inside sales agents, who conduct business primarily over the phone or online, often face repetitive tasks and high-pressure targets. This environment frequently leads to attrition rates that exceed averages in other professions. Companies traditionally rely on financial incentives, such as commissions, to keep these employees motivated and on the payroll.
At the same time, the demographics of the United States workforce are shifting. Hispanic employees represent a rapidly growing segment of the labor market and are taking on an increasing share of sales-related positions. Despite this growth, some industry data suggests that Hispanic sales agents may leave their jobs at higher rates than their non-Hispanic peers. This reality forces managers to ask a difficult question: Do standard motivation strategies work equally well for everyone?
Richard Conde, Victor Prybutok, and Kenneth Thompson investigated this issue to determine if cultural background influences what makes an employee stay. Their findings appeared in the Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice in 2021. The research examines whether the psychological need for independence and mastery outweighs the allure of financial rewards when it comes to employee retention.
Bridging the Gap Between Culture and Motivation
The research team, led by Richard Conde of the University of Houston-Downtown, identified a gap in existing management literature. While many studies look at motivation in general, few have examined how cultural differences might alter the relationship between motivation and job tenure within a single American company. The researchers wanted to know if Hispanic agents, who often come from cultures that emphasize collective goals, respond differently to motivation tactics than those from individualistic cultures.
To explore this, the researchers utilized Cognitive Evaluation Theory (CET). This framework suggests that people have innate psychological needs that drive their behavior. The first need is competence, or the feeling of mastering a task. The second is autonomy, or the feeling that one has control over their own work and choices. When these needs are met, an individual experiences intrinsic motivation. They do the work because they find it satisfying.
By contrast, extrinsic motivation involves doing something to receive a separate outcome, such as avoiding punishment or gaining a financial reward. In many sales organizations, managers assume that increasing extrinsic rewards, like commissions, will automatically lead to better retention. The researchers set out to test this assumption. They also sought to determine if a sales agent’s cultural background changed the way these different types of motivation affected their decision to stay with the company.
Designing the Investigation
The team secured access to a Fortune 100 financial services company. This allowed them to analyze actual operational data rather than relying on surveys where people might misreport their feelings. The study focused on 615 inside sales agents who sold personal insurance policies. The data covered a period from March 2014 to October 2015.
The researchers needed to measure abstract concepts like competence and autonomy using concrete business metrics. To measure competence, they tracked training data. They looked at whether agents participated in extended initial training, refresher courses, or specialized education. They also noted if an agent was skilled enough to serve as a “subject matter expert” for peers. The assumption was that greater access to training and expertise builds a sense of mastery.
To measure autonomy, the study looked at schedule flexibility. Agents in the top 20 percent of performance were allowed to set their own hours. The remaining agents had to bid on shifts. The researchers also looked at “operational adherence.” In call centers, adherence measures how strictly an agent sticks to a pre-set schedule for breaks and lunches. High adherence means the company controls the agent’s minute-by-minute movement. The researchers viewed high adherence scores as an indicator of low autonomy.
For extrinsic motivation, the team calculated the average monthly commission earned by each agent over a six-month period. Finally, they identified the cultural background of the agents to separate the data into Hispanic and non-Hispanic groups. The goal was to see if the link between motivation and tenure looked different for the two groups.
Analyzing the Results
The analysis revealed a clear pattern regarding intrinsic motivation. Agents who experienced higher levels of competence and autonomy stayed with the company significantly longer. Access to training and control over one’s schedule served as strong predictors of retention. This relationship held true regardless of the agent’s cultural background.
The findings regarding financial rewards offered a different perspective. The data showed that earning higher commissions did not lead to longer tenure. In fact, the analysis indicated a negative relationship. Agents who were more driven by extrinsic rewards were slightly more likely to leave the company sooner. The researchers noted that financial incentives can sometimes feel like a form of control, which might diminish an employee’s sense of autonomy.
When the researchers looked for cultural differences, they found that the patterns were identical for both Hispanic and non-Hispanic agents. Being Hispanic did not change the way intrinsic or extrinsic motivation affected tenure. The link between autonomy and staying in the job was strong for everyone. The lack of connection between high commissions and retention was also consistent across both groups.
To ensure the robustness of these findings, the researchers ran an additional test. They separated the agents into top earners and bottom earners to see if the amount of money made a difference. The results remained consistent. Even among top performers, higher pay did not correlate with staying longer. Intrinsic motivation remained the primary factor driving retention for all segments.
Implications for Business Leaders
The study offers several practical takeaways for sales managers and business leaders. The most significant insight is that financial incentives alone are likely insufficient for retaining talent. While commissions are standard in sales, this research suggests they do not encourage loyalty or longevity. Managers might see better retention results by shifting their focus toward psychological needs.
One actionable strategy is to increase employee autonomy. In highly regulated environments like call centers, this can be difficult. However, the study highlights that allowing employees to have a say in their work schedules can make a difference. Giving agents discretion over how they meet their sales goals, rather than micromanaging their activities, could also boost their sense of independence.
Another key area is competence. The data suggests that training should not stop after the onboarding phase. Continuous learning opportunities help employees feel effective and skilled. Managers could implement ongoing education programs or allow experienced agents to train others. These activities foster a sense of mastery that encourages employees to stay.
Regarding diversity, the findings suggest that managers do not need to create separate motivational playbooks for different cultural groups. The psychological needs for autonomy and competence appear to be universal in this professional context. A management style that supports these needs is likely to be effective for a diverse workforce.
There are limitations to consider. The study examined employees at a single company. Corporate culture at that specific organization could have influenced the results. Additionally, the study focused on autonomy and competence but did not measure “relatedness,” which is the sense of belonging and connection with colleagues. Future research might explore how social connections influence retention in diverse teams.
Despite these caveats, the message from the data is consistent. Money may attract a sales agent to the job, but the freedom to work independently and the opportunity to master new skills are what keep them there. This dynamic appears to transcend cultural lines, offering a unified path for managers seeking to stabilize their workforce.
![[Adobe Stock]](https://www.psychologyofselling.pro/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/stressed-businessman-350x250.jpg)
